I love the cookies for my babys birthday, it was a hit!
Custom Photo Cookie - Personalized Printed Sugar Cookie
Not worth the price OR expedited shipping
We ordered cookies with our Nursing Home Logo! They did an amazing job! So many people were impressed! The cookies are the best anyone has ever had! Order yours today , don't delay!!!
We were pleased with them. Will try a different idea next.
The cookies were better than we could have expected! Perfectly designed and tasted amazing! A great treat for any party!
Cookies were magnificent! The photo was beautiful! The cookies were delicious! The wrapping was perfect!! Excellent customer service!!
Will definitely use Eleni’s New York again!!!!❤️
After I placed my order Eleni’s reached out to me to find out when I needed the cookies. They wanted to make sure the cookies were fresh and arrived in time. Our guests loved the taste of the cookies, and someone asked me where I got them. They plan to place an order in the future.
I ordered custom cookies with a photograph of my son on one and the college he’ll be attending next year. Not only were they beautiful, but they were delicious. Everyone loved them.
Amazing as always
We ordered a set of custom cookies and upon submitting the order, customer service reached out right away. They made the experience so seamless and great. And the cookies arrived in excellent condition and tasted great! Looking forward to our next order. Thank you!
Her family members loved them as well.
I can't thank you enough for making the BEST sugar cookies! They are exactly how our family use to bake them. Light, crisp and bursting with flavor. This us nostalgic for me. Addicted!
I was in a pinch, but Eleni and her team made it happen for me with a quick turn around, easy creative process, and delicious treats on time for my sister's baby shower. Thank you!
Each cookie in the Baker's Choice Gift Tin is crispy, tasteful and beautifully packaged. This package is the perfect mixture of classics + fun flavors. It would be ideal for sharing in an office or party, but I kept most for myself!
These cookies are highly enjoyable. They are cozy and crispy in a cookie! I give 4 stars as they aren't my first pick, but still wonderfully made and tasty. If you love oatmeal chocolate chip, these are meant for you
I got the deluxe signature mixed case from Eleni's and it has been everything I was hoping for! I ordered for myself to test, before giving it to someone as a happy and it truly lives up to its name. Every cookie was tasteful, and thoughtfully chosen in its own way! I also love their nut-free and the consistency the crisp cookies hold. If you love cookies or are wanting a gift that is delicious, this case is worth it. I'll absolutely be ordering again!
A perfect treat for when you want something light, sweet, and a classic. I tried multiple of Eleni's crisp cookies, and the pink sugar is definitely my favorite! I have already ordered more.. delicious!
I loved the amount of crunch, and buttery sugar that burst from the birthday cake crisp! The sprinkles on top aren’t just decoration—they add a playful texture and color that makes each cookie feel like a party. Highly recommended for birthdays—or any day that could use a bit of sparkle.
These cookies have a crisp texture, real lemon flavor, and just enough salt to elevate the sweetness without overwhelming it! The packaging is also great, and highly appealing. Will be ordering again
I love Eleni's cookies and was looking for great tasting cookies without dyes as favors for an event I was hosting. I purchased the birthday cake cookies to repackage as favors since I couldn't find any prepackaged available directly from Eleni's. Roughly 30% of the cookies broke before I could repackage them - about 10% upon arrival (the last cookie in every box was broken upon opening) and the rest during handling. I ordered a bit more than needed but it still wasn't enough. Excellent for self consumption though. I wish Eleni's would offer favor or small pack versions of their standard cookies on their website.
Lemon Sea Salt Cookie Box