I was in a pinch, but Eleni and her team made it happen for me with a quick turn around, easy creative process, and delicious treats on time for my sister's baby shower. Thank you!
Each cookie in the Baker's Choice Gift Tin is crispy, tasteful and beautifully packaged. This package is the perfect mixture of classics + fun flavors. It would be ideal for sharing in an office or party, but I kept most for myself!
These cookies are highly enjoyable. They are cozy and crispy in a cookie! I give 4 stars as they aren't my first pick, but still wonderfully made and tasty. If you love oatmeal chocolate chip, these are meant for you
I got the deluxe signature mixed case from Eleni's and it has been everything I was hoping for! I ordered for myself to test, before giving it to someone as a happy and it truly lives up to its name. Every cookie was tasteful, and thoughtfully chosen in its own way! I also love their nut-free and the consistency the crisp cookies hold. If you love cookies or are wanting a gift that is delicious, this case is worth it. I'll absolutely be ordering again!
A perfect treat for when you want something light, sweet, and a classic. I tried multiple of Eleni's crisp cookies, and the pink sugar is definitely my favorite! I have already ordered more.. delicious!
I loved the amount of crunch, and buttery sugar that burst from the birthday cake crisp! The sprinkles on top aren’t just decoration—they add a playful texture and color that makes each cookie feel like a party. Highly recommended for birthdays—or any day that could use a bit of sparkle.
These cookies have a crisp texture, real lemon flavor, and just enough salt to elevate the sweetness without overwhelming it! The packaging is also great, and highly appealing. Will be ordering again
I love Eleni's cookies and was looking for great tasting cookies without dyes as favors for an event I was hosting. I purchased the birthday cake cookies to repackage as favors since I couldn't find any prepackaged available directly from Eleni's. Roughly 30% of the cookies broke before I could repackage them - about 10% upon arrival (the last cookie in every box was broken upon opening) and the rest during handling. I ordered a bit more than needed but it still wasn't enough. Excellent for self consumption though. I wish Eleni's would offer favor or small pack versions of their standard cookies on their website.
The cookies were perfect! We had a silhouette owl in red on some of the cookies and our Executive Headquarters on the others. Our guests loved the special treats. They were beautiful and delicious!
We ordered cookies with specially selected cartoons to thank the nurses who cared for my husband
They were beautiful delicious and memorable!
We got many thank yous for our thank yous!!
The personalized cookies are absolutely adorable! They arrived in perfect order, all in one piece. I appreciate the assistance received from Reagan in designing our party favors. I’m certain they will be the hit of our celebration! 🙌
They are so delicious with the abundance of chocolate chips. The calories are wonderfully low and so I can fully enjoy the rich taste without any guilt. They are the best,
Saw this ad on instagram so I placed my order.. Shipment arrived on time … great customer service .. Wish all retailers were this efficient & caring of their customers
Delicious taste of cookies ..
no doubt , I will be ordering again ..
Such a fun project and rhe team at Elani’s was so helpful and the gift recipient was crazy about them!!!
Can’t tecommend them enough!!!!
Oh my gosh. I am not a sugar cookie lover and I really have never considered a cookie with sugar sprinkles, but I’m SO glad I added this! I will be buying some more. It’s a crispy cookie lovers dream.
Eleni’s Lemon Sea Salt Cookies are a total standout! The crisp texture is spot on, and the balance of tart lemon with a hint of sea salt is perfection. It’s a refreshing twist that’s not too sweet, with just enough zing to keep you coming back for more. They taste fresh and clean, like something you'd get from a high-end bakery. I’ve started keeping a bag on hand for whenever I need a little pick-me-up. If you're a lemon lover, these are a must-try!
Eleni’s Birthday Cake Cookies are seriously addictive! They have that classic birthday cake flavor—sweet, buttery, and full of fun—with colorful sprinkles that make every bite feel like a celebration. The texture is perfectly crisp, just like all of Eleni’s cookies, and they’re not overly sweet, which I really appreciate. These are a big hit in my house with both kids and adults. Whether it's your birthday or not, these cookies are a reason to celebrate!
I picked up Eleni’s Pink Sugar Cookies on a whim, and I’m so glad I did! These cookies are crisp, buttery, and have just the right amount of sweetness. The pink sugar adds a fun, nostalgic touch without being overpowering. They're perfect for a little afternoon treat or to pair with a cup of tea. I love that they have a clean ingredient list and still taste homemade. Definitely my new go-to for when I’m craving something sweet but not too heavy. Highly recommend giving them a try!
Will use again and again
The cookies were exactly what I ordered and shipped quickly. I could not have asked for better and will definitely order again!
I placed a last-minute order, and the cookies came out absolutely adorable! They were delivered super quickly, and the whole process was seamless. Highly recommend!