Based on 79 reviews
90%
(71)
5%
(4)
4%
(3)
0%
(0)
1%
(1)
Great cookies great promotion

As always the cookies were beautiful and tasty. I made 2 orders, one for me, one for my daughter. Looking forward to the Christmas cookies which are tradition in our family.

P
Rectangle Photo Cookie
Patricia Campana
Wow!

I Really loved the cookies! You did an exceptional job and I’m very pleased. I will definitely be using your store again, and I highly recommend you attention to detail.

G
Butterscotch Box
Gina Potts Doss
Love them!

These cookies are my favorite.
I never thought about butterscotch cookies but the taste is addictive.

K
Rectangle Photo Cookie
Kimberly McCreight
Perfect!

Perfect book launch cookies!

J
Ginger Snappy Box
Janis Cochran
Love your Ginger Snaps

Yum, yum, yum.

Pink Sugar Twin Pack

My favorite. Survived shipping well.

Chocolate Chip Twin Pack Box

Chocolate chips were to be a gift. I didn't realize the condition for about a week or so. Twelve of the fourteen packs were broken into pieces. The chips were melted. I saw the UPS truck delivery and retrieved the package before the truck left so any damage happened elsewhere. Needless to say I had to find another gift. Maybe the box should say fragile or perishable. This was a second order. The previous one was in much better condition.

C
Eleni's Classic Six
Cathy Adams-Bomar
Can’t wait to try them

I am delighted with the assortment of cookies and looking for special occasions to share them! The ginger snaps were snapped up by my daughter and the birthday cake cookies will be delivered to my granddaughter on her birthday!

C
Eleni's Classic Six
Catherine Johnson

Best Buy for small gift. Delicious cookies

C
Lemon Sea Salt Box
Cathy Adams-Bomar
Lemon Snaps

I first tasted the Lemon Sea Salt Cookies when I ordered them from Imperfect Foods. I instantly feel in love so I ordered the 6 pack from Eleni’s. The cookies are still good, but the consistency is different, the first ones were softer, more chewy, these ones are definitely crispy.

Best wedding favors

Print quality was perfect, these were rush shipped ahead of schedule and added so much to our party!!

AWESOME!

I've been ordering these for nearly 10 years - always a hit! Such a cute welcome gift for those coming to NYC! Thanks again.

a
Pink Sugar Box
attn buyer

Pink Sugar Box

L
Happy New Year Gift Tin
L.S.L.

Wonderful, cookies, delicious

Sorry but these are just wrong. :-(

Replace the chocolate chips with plump, juicy raisins, and these cookies would be great. I'd buy a ton of them. (I didn't buy these, but I received them as part of a gift package from a friend which also contained the wonderful chocolate chip and ginger cookies.)

These are delicious!

Great flavor, heavy on the ginger and molasses. All good ingredients! My dogs like these too!

Just like homemade, but without the work of baking them!

These taste just like the chocolate chip cookies I make, which is not surprising because Eleni uses the same good ingredients I use. However all of Eleni's chocolate chip cookies are baked to perfection unlike the sometimes slightly burnt or underdone cookies that come out of my oven.

S
Butterscotch Box
Sylvia Renner
Try with red wine!!

These are incredibly crunchy and buttery and happen to be amazing with wine for dessert ! Complex and yummy flavor.

Amazing!

I tried the Eleni's Classic Six and love it! The Ginger Snappy are my favorite, but they are all amazing! Shipping was super fast, and the packaging looks fantastic!

D
Pink Sugar Box
Denny Warnick
Tasty Bits

The service was great, the taste superb but...the cookies were all broken. I was so disappointed. I couldn't serve them to guests. I'm sure I'll get them again though. I hope you find a way to ship crisp cookies. Good luck.

A
Rectangle Photo Cookie
Annabel Massey
Amazing and delicious cookies

Beyond amazing cookies!!!!! Custom with photo!! The absolute best and they taste sooo good

R
Pink Sugar Super Size Box
Rachael Macchiesi

Pink Sugar Super Size Box

B
Signature Tote
Barbara Sullivan
Flimsy Tote but Good Cookies

It was really hard to open and I ended up ripping the tote but the cookies were good as ever.

Crunchy and delicious

My family enjoys chocolate chip cookies and when I started eating Tates I thought I found the perfect cookie.
Sorry to say I was mistaken, these are thin, fresh, and crunchy we all love them.

T
Eleni's Classic Six
Trevis Umble
Amazing Cookes

Great Cookies - Great packaging - super clean ingredients - very crisp an absolutely terrific product!