In observance of Memorial Day, Monday, May 29th 2017 our bakery and cookie concierge will be closed. We will resume normal business hours on Tuesday, May 30th 2017.

Click to Show Notification

JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser.
You must have JavaScript enabled in your browser to utilize the functionality of this website.

Search results for 'Party Favor Package'

Default Category

Small NYC Taxi Cookie Party Favor
$6.50
- | Add to Compare
Funny Farm Gift Set
$34.95
- | Add to Compare
Delicious Dog Shaped Sugar Cookie Gift Set -Woof!
$49.95
- | Add to Compare

Birthday Blast Gift Set
$59.95
- | Add to Compare
Couture Crazy Cat Shaped Sugar Cookie Gift Set
$26.95
- | Add to Compare
Best in Show Poodle Dogs Gift Set
$25.95
- | Add to Compare

All-Star Athlete Gift Tin
$65.00
- | Add to Compare
Pretty Presents Gift Set
$19.00
- | Add to Compare
Travel Essentials Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare

Graduation Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Thank You Note Gift Set
$25.95
- | Add to Compare
Giving Thanks Tree Cookie Gift Set
$25.95
- | Add to Compare

Tool Time Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Apple Cookie Gift Set
Regular Price: $48.50
Special Price $19.40
- | Add to Compare
Fantastic Food Cookout Cookie Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare

Aflutter of Thanks Gift Set
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Mittens Logo Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Snow Day Gift Set (Blue)
$25.95
- | Add to Compare

Snow Day Gift Set (Red)
$25.95
- | Add to Compare
Winter Wonderland Gift Set
$65.00
- | Add to Compare
Snowballs For Sale Gift Set
$32.50
- | Add to Compare

Color Me! Coloring Book Thanksgiving Gift Set
$69.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Book Logo Cookie
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Gramercy Custom Logo Cookie Picture Perfect™ Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare

Union Square Custom Logo Cookie Picture Perfect™ Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Columbus Circle Custom Logo Cookie Picture Perfect™ Gift Set
$46.45
- | Add to Compare
Time Square Custom Logo Cookie Picture Perfect™ Gift Set
$45.00 per gift set
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Small Snowman Logo Cookie
$8.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Large Logo Taxi
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Shopping Bag Logo Cookie
$8.00
- | Add to Compare

Bright Bunny Party Favor Sugar Cookies Set
$35.95
- | Add to Compare
Easter Bright Peep Shaped Sugar Cookie Gift Set
$39.95
- | Add to Compare
Mother Heart Flower Cookie Party Favor
$6.95
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Snowman Large Logo Cookie
$12.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Snowflake Logo Cookie
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Dog House Cookie
$12.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ December 25th Logo Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Snow Day Logo Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Let It Snow Logo Gift Set
$45.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Chilly Treats Logo Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Snow Flurry Logo Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Winter Wonderland Logo Gift Set
$65.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Christmas Morning Logo Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ New York, New York Logo Gift Set
$45.95
- | Add to Compare
Gracious Thank You Corporate Cookies
$29.95
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Apple Party Favor Cookie
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Dreidel, Dreidel Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Great Miracle Dreidels Limited Edition Gift Set
Regular Price: $89.95
Special Price $44.97
- | Add to Compare

Happy Hanukkah Gift Set
Regular Price: $25.95
Special Price $12.97
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Design Your Own Landscape Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Design Your Own Square Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Design Your Own Portrait Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Circle Logo Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $2.25
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Square Logo Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $2.50
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Landscape Logo Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $2.50
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Portrait Logo Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $2.25
- | Add to Compare
Blue Baby Bear Cookie Party Favor
$7.95
- | Add to Compare

Mini Baby Shower Girl Cookie Pink Carriage Party Favor
$4.95
- | Add to Compare
Blue Flag Cake Cookie Party Favor
$8.95
- | Add to Compare
Red Flag Cake Cookie Party Favor
$8.95
- | Add to Compare

Large NYC Taxi Cookie Party Favor
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Large NYPD Police Car Cookie Party Favor
$10.00
- | Add to Compare
Small NYPD Police Car Cookie Party Favor
$6.50
- | Add to Compare

Feel Better Balloons Cookie Party Favor
$7.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Birthday Square Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Birthday Landscape Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ Birthday Portrait Cookie
Price From: $5.00 As low as: $4.00
- | Add to Compare
"Puppy Love" Sugar Cookie Valentine's Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Easter Bunny Shaped Cookies with Sugar Cotton Tails Gift Set
$39.95
- | Add to Compare

Classic White Easter Bunny Party Favor
$7.95
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Easter Rabbit Cookie Party Favor
$5.95
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Easter Egg Cookie Party Favor
$5.95
- | Add to Compare

"Happy St. Patrick's Day" 4 Leaf Clover Sugar Cookie Party Favor
Regular Price: $6.95
Special Price $3.48
- | Add to Compare
Rock n Roll Heart Mom Party Favor
$6.95
- | Add to Compare
Preppy Mom Heart Cookie Party Favor
$6.95
- | Add to Compare

Flower Mom Cookie Party Favor
$6.95
- | Add to Compare
Tiffany Blue Mom Cookie Party Favor
$6.95
- | Add to Compare
Royal Wedding Bracket Cookie Party Favor
$10.00
- | Add to Compare

Flip Flops Cookie Gift Set
$42.95
- | Add to Compare
American Flag Cookie Party Favor
$5.00
- | Add to Compare
Pink Baby Bear Cookie Party Favor
$7.95
- | Add to Compare

Get Well Soon Balloons Cookie Party Favor
$7.95
- | Add to Compare
School Days Cookie Gift Set
$25.95
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Barnyard Gift Set
$39.95
- | Add to Compare

Color Me! Dinosaurs Gift Set
$39.95
- | Add to Compare
Ladies Tennis Cookie Gift Set
$29.95
- | Add to Compare
Candy Canes & Holly Gift Set
$58.50
- | Add to Compare

Color Me! Coloring Book Christmas Party Gift Set
$69.95
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Coloring Book Ugly Sweater Party Gift Tin
Regular Price: $69.95
Special Price $34.97
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Coloring Book Easter Party Tin
$69.95
- | Add to Compare

ConGRADulations! School Logo Cookie Custom Gift
$59.95
- | Add to Compare
Fun in the Sun Gift Set
$49.95
- | Add to Compare
Sugar Skulls Limited Edition Gift Set
$99.00
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ NFL Arizona Cardinals Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ NFL Baltimore Ravens Football Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ NFL Buffalo Bills Football Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare

NFL Sugar Cookie New England Patriot Football Gift
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ NFL New Orleans Saints Football Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ NFL New York Giants Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare

Picture Perfect™ NFL Washington Redskins Football Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare
Color Me! Coloring Book Hearts Party Tin
$69.95
- | Add to Compare
Picture Perfect™ Super Bowl LII NFL Football Tin
$54.95
- | Add to Compare

Beach Party Cookie Gift Set
$65.95
- | Add to Compare

Eleni’s Cookies also available in…